• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Buttercooky Bakery

Founded in Floral Park, NY, Buttercooky Bakery is a go-to spot for custom cakes, pastries, and desserts. Their winter/holiday treats like the Dubai Chocolate Croissant with Pistachio and Kunafa Filling are a must-try. Not to mention their delicious pies, breakfast pastries, and mini cakes that keep customers coming back for more. The bakery has received rave reviews for their friendly staff and delectable treats, with customers praising the tres leches cake and unique custom cake options. With a welcoming atmosphere and a wide variety of tasty treats to choose from, Buttercooky Bakery is a hidden gem worth visiting.

Buttercooky Bakery: Reviews & Ratings

Kim J.
Kim J.

1 million stars!!! Benny I love ya! I have been a customer I believe since he opened and my grandmother has been a customer ever since. The pastries have been flown to many states with my family over the years. I refuse to go to any other bakery when in NY. This family is a wonderful, hardworking bunch. And their workers are helpful and knowledgeable as well. Thank you for always being my cannolis supply all the way to Missouri.

Jennifer L.
Jennifer L.

Been buying cakes here for years. Had a custom vintage heart cake made for my birthday. Went in a week before and custom ordered the cake. go as early as possible because it does get busy. Buttercream and passion fruit. Show them a picture and they can do it. They also just had a revamp so inside is so nice.

Hasna D.
Hasna D.

I have been going to this bakery for over 10 years. Staff is great, and let me tell you the tres leches cake is my weakness!!! They also have mini cakes which is nice!! Loveeee this bakery!!

Carol W.
Carol W.

One of my favorite bakeries. The visuals of the pastries and cakes alone make your mouth water. Can't help but leave with a bag full of goodies.

Crystal G.
Crystal G.

Delicious!! This place is heavenly. So many tasty treats to choose from. The people were very helpful and the banana pastry I had was fresh and delicious. The horn pastry was filled with the richest most delicious fluffy cream. I was in pig heaven. I also had a delightful freshly brewed coffee. The shop is bright, clean and inviting. I cannot wait for a good excuse to return.

Revathi N.
Revathi N.

Thank you for our delicious cake that we had at our reception at Floral Terrace on June 15th. Everyone was raving about the flavor, design, and it was everything that I had ever wished for in a wedding cake! Please give my sincere thanks to all the staff and to everyone that worked hard in creating our dream cake. We had a hazelnut sponge cake with vanilla buttercream filled with french cream. DELICIOUS and BEAUTIFUL!

Natalie L.
Natalie L.

Good service employees are so nice and helpful. Great pastries, cakes, and cookies. There're prices are reasonable. Wide variety of different sizes and types of cakes. For my coworker's birthday the office purchased a tres leches birthday cake. The cake was delicious not to sweet love the fruit on top. I decided to see if they had the same cake in slices. They don't have slices they have it served in a small size dish for $ 9.75 (it's enough for 2 people). They also serve coffee and tea and a nice seating area. I will definitely purchase a cake for future events.

Location

Introducing Buttercooky Bakery, a delightful haven for custom cakes, pastries, and desserts in Floral Park, NY. This bakery not only offers a wide range of sweet treats but also provides amenities such as delivery, takeout, and catering services. Whether you're looking for a gluten-free option or a delectable holiday treat, Buttercooky Bakery has you covered.

Located at 217 Jericho Turnpike, Buttercooky Bakery is a must-visit destination for all dessert lovers. From the Dubai Chocolate Croissant with Pistachio and Kunafa Filling to the Mini Key Lime Pie and Pumpkin Loaf Slice, their menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options that will leave you craving for more.

Customer reviews rave about the quality of the pastries and cakes, with many loyal patrons praising the staff's helpfulness and the bakery's inviting atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a classic apple turnover or a decadent piece of Pecan Pie, Buttercooky Bakery is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

With a loyal following and a reputation for outstanding desserts, Buttercooky Bakery is a hidden gem in Floral Park that deserves to be on every foodie's radar. So, next time you're in the mood for a delicious treat, be sure to stop by and indulge in the sweet delights that Buttercooky Bakery has to offer.